Home > Government & Legislation > Airport Body Scanners a Breach of Privacy?

Airport Body Scanners a Breach of Privacy?

By: Garry Crystal - Updated: 29 May 2016 | comments*Discuss
 
Body Scanners Airport Right To Privacy

The introduction of airport body scanners in the UK has brought about much controversy. Objections to the body scanners include risks to the public’s right to privacy and breach of discrimination laws.

How Do The Airport Body Scanners Work?

There are different types of body scanners but in generally the scanners emit radio waves over the body. A three dimensional image is created by measuring the heat reflected from the person. The body scanners can penetrate clothing and are designed to be an upgrade to the usual body pat down. The scans do blur out faces but the image does reveal the naked body.

Why The Need for Full Body Scanners?

According to the UK government the airport body scanners are just the latest security technology used in the fight against terrorism. The alleged attempt to blow up a US plane on December 25th 2009 is being touted as the main reason this technology is required. The UK Home Secretary claims that no single technology will be enough to safeguard against terrorism but that the scanners are a step in the right direction. Others have called the scanners an intrusion of privacy and a deeply flawed method of detection.

Why The Controversy Over the Airport Body Scanners?

The Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) have warned that airport body scanners are breaching rights such as the right to privacy. Not only will the scanners show the naked body but they may be able to show images of mastectomies, prosthetic limbs and catheters. Certain groups such as children, transgendered individuals and the elderly are being cited as examples of people who will be negatively affected by lack of privacy.

Are The Scanners Really Breaching Privacy Laws?

In reality, the body scanners are virtual strip searches. A code of practice has already been set in place for the scanners but no consultation was taken before the code was introduced. Anyone in the UK who refuses a body scan will automatically be banned from flying. In America passengers can refuse and are given the alternative of a pat down or a metal arch detector. According to the EHRC these scanners do go against the right to privacy under the Human Rights Act.

Have Any Passenger Been Banned For Flying?

There have been news reports of passengers stopped from boarding a plane after refusing a body scan. Two women were recently not permitted to fly after refusing on grounds of religious beliefs and health issues. According to certain Islamic scholars the use of body scanners does go against the beliefs of Muslims. Modesty is part of the Islamic faith and for others to view the naked bodies of Muslim men and women is an affront to their religion.

Are Airport Scanners Rolling Out Across Europe?

Although the scanners are now in place in certain airports in the UK not all European Union countries are in agreement. There are 27 EU countries that are free to use the body scanners but some are indecisive about the scanners validity and the breach of rights implications. Italy is introducing the scanners at certain airports as an experiment only. Spain has decided to wait until it hears the results of the European Commission’s decision on the matter.

Is the Use of Airport Body Scanners Justifiable?

According to the government the recent acts of terrorism are justifiable cause for implementing body scanners. But when it comes to privacy laws it may be a different matter. The Human Rights Act states that there must be justifiable causes to any infringement to the right of privacy. Any infringement to the right of privacy must also be necessary and proportionate. The fact that passengers are not being offered alternative search methods does look like an infringement of privacy.

Are The Body Scanners Here to Stay?

It looks as though the airport scanners will be rolled out across UK airports throughout 2010. But the EHRC wants answers from the government over its future plans for the scanners. The Equality and Human Rights Commission has warned the government that the utmost caution must be used when implementing this technology especially when it comes to privacy. The EHRC also want the government to fully explain its intentions for the use of body scanners in the future.

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
I wonder if you could help me. I'm disabled paralysed from waist down.I use a wheelchair.. I normally travel on my own going abroad during winter months because I get ill with cold weather.During the time I travel I use a catheter.I was stopped by security. When I missed the flight I remember passing through tight security.I wonder if I was sent through the body scanners.Still when I missed the flight I spent a very cold night on my wheelchair without any proper hot meal or blanket. I spent four days to reach my destination instead of one night. I wonder of somebody could help me. I now suffer from infections and arthritis since that incident.Please can you advise me?
Eretina - 29-May-16 @ 12:40 AM
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice...
Title:
(never shown)
Firstname:
(never shown)
Surname:
(never shown)
Email:
(never shown)
Nickname:
(shown)
Comment:
Validate:
Enter word:
Topics
Latest Comments
  • Bob
    Re: The Police and Your Civil Rights
    Somebody is entering my house. I suspect the police. my forst and second wives both had affarid with police officers, one…
    22 April 2017
  • adam
    Re: The Facts on Racial Profiling
    Racial profiling is very real and carried out not only by Police but Judges at the courts. I suffered from open and proud racism…
    22 April 2017
  • CivilRightsMovement
    Re: Protecting Your Privacy
    Tash - Your Question:I've had problems with my neighbour since he moved in. He stunk my house out with weed, not sure if he was growing…
    19 April 2017
  • john
    Re: Civil Rights and Security Issues
    have been harrassed by police in secret for a few years now since i caught one of their internet police officers trying to…
    19 April 2017
  • Tash
    Re: Protecting Your Privacy
    I've had problems with my neighbour since he moved in. He stunk my house out with weed, not sure if he was growing it or smoking lots of…
    16 April 2017
  • Nikki
    Re: The Police and Your Civil Rights
    My sister smokes a joint or 2 for pain relief she has a rare form of arthritis when she call to my house she will smoke this…
    14 April 2017
  • Bosie
    Re: The Police and Your Civil Rights
    An assistant investigator working for the U.K. Police sent an email to my place of work stating I was a "person of interest"…
    13 April 2017
  • Mercedees888
    Re: The Police and Your Civil Rights
    Police came to my house with a search warrant and arrested my 19 year old son . They said that they have tell me to leave my…
    12 April 2017
  • CivilRightsMovement
    Re: The Police and Your Civil Rights
    Dale - Your Question:After any fight my husband refuses to give me car keys. He always threatens you not gonna get a car and…
    11 April 2017
  • Dale
    Re: The Police and Your Civil Rights
    After any fight my husband refuses to give me car keys. He always threatens you not gonna get a car and hides the keys. We…
    10 April 2017
Further Reading...
Our Most Popular...
Add to my Yahoo!
Add to Google
Stumble this
Add to Twitter
Add To Facebook
RSS feed
You should seek independent professional advice before acting upon any information on the CivilRightsMovement website. Please read our Disclaimer.