Home > Ask Our Experts > Are Biometric Cards For Children's Dinner Payments Ethical?

Are Biometric Cards For Children's Dinner Payments Ethical?

By: Garry Crystal - Updated: 9 Nov 2016 | comments*Discuss
 
Biometric Cards School Dinners Data

Q.

My local school is implementing biometric cards for children in order to make payments for school dinners, (in the newsletter received I am told several schools have already adopted this system). If they refuse they then will not have access to food at school.

This will involve taking my child's finger print to put on the card - something I am not happy with. Is this an infringment of her rights as the only other time your prints are required is if you are a criminal suspect.. or for work security.

Please can you advise me on this as it will start soon and I feel all parents should at least question this.

(P.W, 11 March 2009)

A.

There has been much controversy over biometric cards and the use of this technology in schools. The biometric technology scans fingerprints and is used for identification and data gathering. This technology has been used in schools in recent years to access services such as libraries and gaining access to school buildings. Biometric cards used in dinner situations known as the cashless school dinner system has come under fire from both parents and MPs. As far back as 2007 the government warned schools that the policy of 'no fingerprints, no food' could actually be illegal.

Parental Permission

The question of parental permission and biometric cards has also been under dispute since the system was introduced. According to the educational technology agency Becta, the Data Protection Act stipulates that there is no actual specific need to seek permission. Pupils should be told that the system is being used and if the pupil is too young to understand then parents should be informed.

Becta has advised schools that parents should be kept informed as much as possible. Under the rules of the Human Rights Act the gathering of pupil’s personal data can be justified if it is in the school’s interests.

Opting Out of the Biometric Card System

If parents do refuse to give permission for their children to use the system then an alternative lunch should be provided. However, the Department for Education and Skills has stated that the alternative lunch system will be up to the schools to decide. Some schools have provided an alternative such as paying for food and others have simply left the alternative as packed lunches.

Biometric Controversy

Issues surrounding the biometric cards include identity theft, privacy issues and the fact that some schools are not consulting parents when introducing the system. Schools have insisted that no records of fingerprints will be kept and it is a way to keep an eye on what children are eating every day. It is also claimed that the biometric system will help remove the stigma associated with free school dinners. However, parents have formed groups around the country to protest against what they see as an invasion of their children’s rights.

Implementing Biometric Systems

At the moment it seems that schools can implement these systems without parent’s permission, although parents can refuse to allow their children to use the system. Much has been said over the government introducing biometric systems whenever and wherever they can. Alternatives that could have been used in schools for cashless dinner systems do include smart cards where no fingerprints are needed.

Under the Data Protection Act all data must be held securely and be kept for no longer than necessary. Parents should be aware that schools are the 'data controllers' and it is up to the schools to decide the purpose of the data and how it is processed. Parents who are concerned can find more information on the school dinner biometric system at the website Leave Them Kids Alone.

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
Help! - Your Question:
Help ASAP!Is it legal or illegal for a police officer to say to you. If you come to the station or allow me to drive you to the station you have nothing to worry about we are not going to arrest you, or detain you and you don't need a lawyer?Do you have any official papers, codes of conduct or laws police are expected to abide by?Thank,Glenn

Our Response:
You've not given details of the circumstances or why the police wanted to take you to the station so the best we can provide you with is the government information relating to the police guidelines PACE (Police and Criminal Evidence Act)
CivilRightsMovement - 10-Nov-16 @ 11:42 AM
Help ASAP! Is it legal or illegal for a police officer to say to you. If you come to the station or allow me to drive you to the station you have nothing to worry about we are not going to arrest you, or detain you and you don't need a lawyer? Do you have any official papers, codes of conduct or laws police are expected to abide by? Thank, Glenn
Help! - 9-Nov-16 @ 2:31 PM
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice...
Title:
(never shown)
Firstname:
(never shown)
Surname:
(never shown)
Email:
(never shown)
Nickname:
(shown)
Comment:
Validate:
Enter word:
Topics
Latest Comments
  • JimT
    Re: Challenging the Police
    Hi, My house was recently broken into but we weren't present. Our neighbours called the police at least twice, possibly 3 times, once…
    23 June 2017
  • David
    Re: Rights If Your Child is Arrested
    My brother has been assaulted by 12-14 yr old and left him with a bloody face with blood everywhere. What can be done about…
    22 June 2017
  • That Girl
    Re: Anti Social Behaviour Orders, ASBOs: Your Rights
    Had an issue yesterday with a driver blocking me in. It ended in a shouting match. The police issued me…
    21 June 2017
  • Hmmmpth
    Re: Is the Mosquito Alarm an Infringement on Human Rights?
    So the poor kids that have to put up with this high pitched noise are having their human rights…
    20 June 2017
  • Fred
    Re: The Rights of a Victim of Crime
    What about the right of a suspect or defendant to justice ? I recently pleaded guilty to a minor criminal offence for tactical…
    17 June 2017
  • CivilRightsMovement
    Re: Challenging the Police
    Yasmin - Your Question:HiMy partner was arrested 2 months ago but he was released without being charged. In the process of the arrest some…
    16 June 2017
  • CivilRightsMovement
    Re: Protecting Your Privacy
    Bicquette - Your Question:We caught our neighbours twice taking picture of private letters left on our front seat in the car on our…
    16 June 2017
  • Bruce
    Re: FAQ: Are Smokers Losing Their Civil Rights?
    To me it seems smokers are a minority that people are being allowed to discriminate agianst due to the campaign…
    15 June 2017
  • Tal
    Re: The Rights of a Victim of Crime
    Why cant you claim compensation after 2years I went through domestic violence and the only thing I was thinking of at the time…
    15 June 2017
  • Yasmin
    Re: Challenging the Police
    Hi My partner was arrested 2 months ago but he was released without being charged. In the process of the arrest some of my property was…
    13 June 2017
Further Reading...
Our Most Popular...
Add to my Yahoo!
Add to Google
Stumble this
Add to Twitter
Add To Facebook
RSS feed
You should seek independent professional advice before acting upon any information on the CivilRightsMovement website. Please read our Disclaimer.